Sergei Pankejeff
Sergei Pankejeff | |
|---|---|
.JPG) Pankejeff in 1915 | |
| Born | Сергей Константинович Панкеев 24 December 1886 Odesa, Russian Empire |
| Died | 7 May 1979 (aged 92) Vienna, Austria |
| Other names | Wolf Man |
Sergei Konstantinovitch Pankejeff (Russian: Серге́й Константи́нович Панке́ев; 24 December 1886 – 7 May 1979) was a Russian aristocrat from Odesa, Russian Empire. Pankejeff is best known for being a patient of Sigmund Freud, who gave him the pseudonym of Wolf Man (German: der Wolfsmann) to protect his identity, after a dream Pankejeff had of a tree full of white wolves.
Biography
[edit]
Early life and education
[edit]Pankejeff was born on the 24 December 1886 at his family's estate near Kakhovka on the river Dnieper.[1] The Pankejeff family (Freud's German transliteration from the Russian; in English it would be transliterated as Pankeyev) was a wealthy family in St. Petersburg.
His father was Konstantin Matviyovich Pankeyev and his mother was Anna Semenivna, née Shapovalova.
Pankejeff's parents were married young and had a happy marriage, but his mother became sickly and was therefore somewhat absent from the lives of her two children. Pankejeff would later describe her as cold and lacking tenderness, though she would show special affection to him when he was sickly.[2][1]
His father Konstantin, while being a cultured man and a keen hunter, was also an alcoholic who suffered from depressive episodes. He had been treated by Moshe Wulff (a disciple of Freud). He would later be diagnosed by Kraepelin with manic depressive disorder. His mother (Pankejeff's grandmother) had fallen into a depressive state after the death of a daughter and was thought to have died of suicide,[1] while a paternal uncle of Pankejeff's was diagnosed with paranoia by the neuropsychiatrist Korsakov and admitted to an asylum.[3][1]
Sergei and his sister Anna were brought up by two servants; Nanja and Grusha and an English governess named Miss Oven. Sergei's education would later be taken over by male tutors.
Sergei attended a grammar school in Russia, but after the 1905 Russian Revolution he spent considerable time abroad studying.
Psychological problems
[edit]During his review of Freud's letters and other files, Jeffrey Moussaieff Masson uncovered notes for an unpublished paper by Freud's associate Ruth Mack Brunswick. Freud had asked her to review the Pankejeff case, and she discovered evidence that Pankejeff had been sexually abused by a family member during his childhood.[4]
In 1906, his older sister Anna committed suicide through the use of quicksilver while visiting the site of Mikhail Lermontov's fatal duel. She would die after two weeks of agony.
By 1907, Sergei began to show signs of serious depression. Sergei's father Konstantin also suffered from depression, often connected to specific political happenings of the day, and committed suicide in 1907 by consuming an excess of sleeping medication, a few months after Sergei had left for Munich to seek treatment for his own ailment. While in Munich, Pankejeff saw many doctors and stayed voluntarily at a number of elite psychiatric hospitals. In the summers, he always visited Russia.
During a stay in Kraepelin's sanatorium near Neuwittelsbach, he met a nurse who worked there, Theresa-Maria Keller, whom he fell in love with and wanted to marry.
Pankejeff's family upon learning about the relationship was against it, as not only was Keller from a lower class, but also she was older than Pankejeff and a divorced woman with a daughter.
The couple would marry in 1914.
Der Wolfsmann (The Wolf Man)
[edit]
In January 1910, Pankejeff's physician Leonid Drosnes[5] brought him to Vienna to have treatment with Freud. Pankejeff and Freud met with each other many times between February 1910 and July 1914, and a few times thereafter, including a brief psychoanalysis in 1919. Pankejeff's "nervous problems" included his inability to have bowel movements without the assistance of an enema, as well as debilitating depression. Initially, according to Freud, Pankejeff resisted opening up to full analysis, until Freud gave him a year deadline for analysis, prompting Pankejeff to give up his resistances.
Freud's first publication on the "Wolf Man" was "From the History of an Infantile Neurosis" (Aus der Geschichte einer infantilen Neurose), written at the end of 1914, but not published until 1918. Freud's treatment of Pankejeff centered on a dream the latter had as a very young child which he described to Freud:
- I dreamt that it was night and that I was lying in bed. (My bed stood with its foot towards the window; in front of the window there was a row of old walnut trees. I know it was winter when I had the dream, and night-time.) Suddenly the window opened of its own accord, and I was terrified to see that some white wolves were sitting on the big walnut tree in front of the window. There were six or seven of them. The wolves were quite white, and looked more like foxes or sheep-dogs, for they had big tails like foxes and they had their ears pricked like dogs when they pay attention to something. In great terror, evidently of being eaten up by the wolves, I screamed and woke up. My nurse hurried to my bed, to see what had happened to me. It took quite a long while before I was convinced that it had only been a dream; I had had such a clear and life-like picture of the window opening and the wolves sitting on the tree. At last I grew quieter, felt as though I had escaped from some danger, and went to sleep again.(Freud 1918)
Freud's eventual analysis (along with Pankejeff's input) of the dream was that it was the result of Pankejeff having witnessed a "primal scene" — his parents having sex a tergo or more ferarum ("from behind" or "doggy style") — at a very young age. Later in the paper, Freud posited the possibility that Pankejeff instead had witnessed copulation between animals, which was displaced to his parents.
Pankejeff's dream played a major role in Freud's theory of psychosexual development, and along with Irma's injection (Freud's own dream, which launched dream analysis), it was one of the most important dreams for the developments of Freud's theories. Additionally, Pankejeff became one of the main cases used by Freud to prove the validity of psychoanalysis. It was the third detailed case study, after "Notes Upon a Case of Obsessional Neurosis" in 1908 (also known by its animal nickname "Rat Man"), that did not involve Freud analyzing himself, and which brought together the main aspects of catharsis, the unconscious, sexuality, and dream analysis put forward by Freud in his Studies on Hysteria (1895), The Interpretation of Dreams (1899), and his Three Essays on the Theory of Sexuality (1905).
Later life
[edit]Pankejeff later published his own memoir under Freud's given pseudonym and remained in contact with Freudian disciples until his own death (undergoing analysis for six decades despite Freud's pronouncement of his being "cured"), making him one of the longest-running famous patients in the history of psychoanalysis.
A few years after finishing psychoanalysis with Freud, Pankejeff developed a psychotic delirium. He was observed in a street staring at his reflection in a mirror, convinced that after a having consulted and been treated by a dermatologist to correct a minor injury on his nose; his dermatologist had left him with what he perceived to be a hole in his nose. This obsession with this perceived flaw led to an obsessive compulsion to look at himself “in every shop window; he carried a pocket mirror … his fate depended on what it revealed or was about to reveal." Ruth Mack Brunswick, a Freudian, explained the delusion as displaced castration anxiety.
Having lost most of his family's wealth after the Russian Revolution, Pankejeff supported himself and his wife on his salary as an insurance clerk.[6]
The psychoanalytical movement[7] also provided Pankejeff with financial support in Vienna; psychoanalysts like Kurt Eissler (a former student of Freuds) dissuaded Pankejeff from talking to any media.[8] The reason for this was that Pankejeff being one of Freuds most famous "cured" patients and the fact revealing that he was still suffering from mental illness[9] would hurt the reputation of Freud and psychoanalysis. Pankejeff was essentially bribed to keep quiet.[7]
In 1938, Pankejeffs wife committed suicide by inhaling gas. She had been depressed since the death of her daughter.[10] As this coincided with the Anschluss; and the suicide wave among Jews who were trapped in Austria, research has also suggested that she was actually Jewish[10] and that her suicide was prompted by her fear of the Nazis.
Facing a major crisis and not being able to get help from Mack Brunswick who had fled to Paris Pankejeff approached Muriel Gardiner who managed to get him a visa to travel there. He would later follow her to London before returning to Vienna in 1938.
Throughout the following decades, Pankejeff would go through some emotional crises which would ultimately lead to him becoming depressive. One of them being the death of Pankejeffs mother in 1953.[11]
Pankejeff would receive intermittent treatment for these episodes from various psychoanalysts most frequently by the head of The Vienna Psychoanalytical Society Alfred von Winterstein and then by his successor Wilhelm Solms-Rödelheim.[11]
Gardiner would also supply him with "wonder pills" (Dexamyl) to help Pankejeff alleviate his emotional turmoil.
In July 1977, Pankejeff suffered a heart attack and then contracted pneumonia. He was admitted to the Steinhof psychiatric hospital in Vienna.
Now Pankejeff broke his silence and agreed to talk to Karin Obholzer. Their[12]conversations, which took place between January 1974 to September 1976, would later be recounted in the book "Conversations with the Wolf-Man Sixty years later" in 1980, after Pankejeffs death and per his own wishes. In Pankejeffs own words, his treatment by Freud had been "catastrophi".[7]
Death
[edit]Pankejeff died on the 12th of May 1979 at the age of 92.
Criticism of Freud's interpretation
[edit]Critics, beginning with Otto Rank in 1926, have questioned the accuracy and efficacy of Freud's psychoanalytic treatment of Pankejeff.[13] Similarly, in the mid-20th century, psychiatrist Hervey Cleckley dismissed Freud's diagnosis as far-fetched and entirely speculative.[14] Dorpat has suggested that Freud's behavior in the Pankejeff case as an example of gaslighting (attempting to undermine someone's perceptions of reality).[15]
Daniel Goleman wrote in 1990 in the New York Times:
Freud's key intervention with the Wolf Man rested on a nightmare in which he was lying in bed and saw some white wolves sitting on a tree in front of the open window. Freud deduced that the dream symbolized a trauma: that the Wolf Man, as a toddler, had witnessed his parents having intercourse. Freud's version of the supposed trauma, however, was contradicted by the Wolf Man himself, Sergej Pankejeff, in an interview with Karin Obholzer, a journalist who tracked him down in Vienna in the 1970s.
Mr. Pankejeff saw Freud's interpretation of his dream as 'terribly far-fetched.' Mr. Pankejeff said, 'The whole thing is improbable,' since in families of his milieu young children slept in their nanny's bedroom, not with their parents.
Mr. Pankejeff also disputed Freud's claim that he had been cured, and said he resented being 'propaganda' and 'a showpiece for psychoanalysis.' Mr. Pankejeff said, 'That was the theory, that Freud had cured me 100 percent.' However, 'It's all false.'[16]
— Daniel Goleman, 6 March 1990
Mária Török and Nicolas Abraham have reinterpreted the Wolf Man's case (in The wolf man's magic word, a cryptonymy), presenting their notion of "the crypt" and what they call “cryptonyms." They provide a different analysis of the case than Freud, whose conclusions they criticise. According to the authors, Pankejeff's statements hide other statements, while the actual content of his words can be illuminated by looking into his multi-lingual background. According to the authors, Pankejeff hid secrets concerning his older sister, and as the Wolf Man both wanted to forget and preserve these issues, he encrypted his older sister, as an idealised "other" in the heart of himself, and spoke these secrets out loud in a cryptic manner, through words hiding behind words, rebuses, wordplays etc. For example, in the Wolf Man's dream, where six or seven wolves were sitting in a tree outside his bedroom window, the expression "pack of six", a "sixter" = shiestorka: siestorka = sister, which gives the conclusion that his sister is placed in the centre of the trauma.
The case forms a central part of the second plateau of Gilles Deleuze and Félix Guattari's A Thousand Plateaus, titled "One or Several Wolves?" In it, they repeat the accusation made in Anti-Oedipus that Freudian analysis is unduly reductive and that the unconscious is actually a "machinic assemblage". They argue that wolves are a case of the pack or multiplicity and that the dream was part of a schizoid experience.
See also
[edit]Notes
[edit]- ^ a b c d Gardiner, Muriel (22 March 2018). The Wolf-Man and Sigmund Freud. Routledge. ISBN 978-0-429-92278-7.
- ^ Buirski, Peter (September 2007). Practicing Intersubjectively. Jason Aronson. ISBN 978-0-7657-0383-5.
- ^ Roudinesco, Élisabeth (7 November 2016). Freud: In His Time and Ours. Harvard University Press. ISBN 978-0-674-65956-8.
- ^ "Anally seduced" as Masson writes, using Freud's "seduction" as an umbrella term for sexual maltreatment. Masson, Jeffrey Moussaieff. (1984) The Assault On Truth: Freud's Suppression of The Seduction Theory. Pocket Books, 1984, 1998. ISBN 0-671-02571-6
- ^ May, Ulrike (11 July 2018). Freud at Work: On the History of Psychoanalytic Theory and Practice, with an Analysis of Freud's Patient Record Books. Routledge. ISBN 978-0-429-75903-1.
- ^ Smirnova, О.V.; Denisova, G.V.; Pankeyev, I.А.; Ilchenko, D.S.; Antipova, А.S. (2023). "Short-Term Semantic Changes in Space-Related Categories in Russian Media Discourse". Научно-техническая информация Серия 1 Организация и методика информационной работы (3): 24–32. doi:10.36535/0548-0019-2023-03-4. ISSN 0548-0019.
- ^ a b c Dufresne, Todd (19 September 2006). Killing Freud: Twentieth Century Culture and the Death of Psychoanalysis. A&C Black. ISBN 978-0-8264-9339-2.
- ^ Frank Sulloway, "qui a peur de l'homme aux loups", in: Le livre noir de la psychanalyse, éditions les Arènes, Paris, 2005,p 84
- ^ Dolnick, Edward (1998). Madness on the Couch: Blaming the Victim in the Heyday of Psychoanalysis. Simon and Schuster. ISBN 978-0-684-82497-0.
- ^ a b Etkind, Alexander (13 March 2019). Eros of the Impossible: The History of Psychoanalysis in Russia. Routledge. ISBN 978-0-429-72088-8.
- ^ a b Borch-Jacobsen, Mikkel (13 October 2021). Freud's Patients: A Book of Lives. Reaktion Books. ISBN 978-1-78914-454-3.
- ^ Dolnick, Edward (1998). Madness on the Couch: Blaming the Victim in the Heyday of Psychoanalysis. Simon and Schuster. ISBN 978-0-684-82497-0.
- ^ The Letters of Sigmund Freud and Otto Rank: Inside Psychoanalysis (eds. E. J. Lieberman and Robert Kramer). Baltimore: Johns Hopkins University Press. 2012.
- ^ "I have become increasingly convinced that some of the popular methods presumed to discover what is in the unconscious cannot be counted upon as reliable methods of obtaining evidence. They often involve the use of symbolism and analogy in such a way that the interpreter can find virtually anything that he is looking for. Freud, for instance, from a simple dream reported by a man in his middle twenties as having occurred at 4 years of age drew remarkable conclusions. The 4-year-old boy dreamed of seeing six or seven white wolves sitting in a tree. Freud interpreted the dream in such a way as to convince himself that the patient at 18 months of age had been shocked by seeing his parents have intercourse three times in succession and that this played a major part in the extreme fear of being castrated by his father which Freud ascribed to him at 4 years of age. No objective evidence was ever offered to support this conclusion. Nor was actual fear of castration ever made to emerge into the light of consciousness despite years of analysis." Hervey Cleckley, The Mask of Sanity, 1941, fifth edition 1976, ISBN 0-9621519-0-4
- ^ Dorpat, Theodore L. (28 October 1996). Gaslighting, the double whammy, interrogation, and other methods of covert control in psychotherapy and psychoanalysis. J. Aronson. ISBN 978-1-56821-828-1. Retrieved 16 June 2011.
- ^ Goleman, Daniel (6 March 1990). "As a Therapist, Freud Fell Short, Scholars Find". The New York Times. ISSN 0362-4331. Retrieved 2 September 2022.
References
[edit]- Whitney Davis, Drawing the Dream of the Wolves: Homosexuality, Interpretation and Freud's 'Wolf Man' (Indianapolis: Indiana University Press, 1995), ISBN 978-0-253-20988-7.
- Sigmund Freud, "From the History of an Infantile Neurosis" (1918), reprinted in Peter Gay, The Freud Reader (London: Vintage, 1995).
- Muriel Gardiner, The Wolf-Man and Sigmund Freud, London, Routledge, 1971
- Karin Obholzer, The Wolf-Man Sixty Years Later, tr. M. Shaw, London, Routledge & P. Kegan, 1982, p. 36.
- Patrick J. Mahony, Cries of the WolfMan, New York : International Universities Press, 1984
- "The Wolf-Man" [Sergei Pankejeff], The Wolf-Man (Pankejeff's memoirs, along with essays by Freud and Ruth Mack Brunswick), (New York: Basic Books, 1971).
- James L. Rice, Freud's Russia: National Identity in the Evolution of Psychoanalysis (New Brunswick, NJ: Transaction Publishers, 1993), 94–98. ISBN 1-56000-091-0
- Torok Maria, Abraham Nicolas, The wolf man's magic word, a cryptonymy, 1986
External links
[edit]
